SourceURL:file://localhost/Users/genevievegillespie/Desktop/2011%20Fall%20Course%20Notes%20and%20Docs/nml%20week%205%20quest%20response.doc @font-face { font-family: “Times New Roman”; }p.MsoNormal, li.MsoNormal, div.MsoNormal { margin: 0in 0in 0.0001pt; font-size: 12pt; font-family: “Times New Roman”; }table.MsoNormalTable { font-size: 10pt; font-family: “Times New Roman”; }div.Section1 { page: Section1; }
There are a number of things I greatly appreciate about the “gaming pedagogy” theory employed at Quest to Learn School in New York. I predict that the emphasis they place on questioning as the foundation of knowledge and understanding will greatly increase student initiatives and encourage more interactive learning, as opposed to authoritative pedagogy. Questioning learners become skeptics and scientists, two discourses the world needs more of. Furthermore, the student’s questions will be less intimidating because the system-based learning gives students direct access to the tools that hold the keys to answers and problem solutions. As a student, I was often deterred from inquiry because I could not understand structures upon which abstraction or fact was based, and was subsequently a highly selective learner, only absorbing that which was not based on complex and all-together alien systems. Quest kids have the advantage of an education based in systemic roots, laying the groundwork for well-informed analysis and adept problem solving later on in life and strengthening their critical thinking skills, helping them to formulate connections between different systems.
There are some flaws with this pedagogy, however. Firstly, it reinforces the import of experience and not application. I feel as if there are basic abstractions that need to be introduced before the students are expected to create games that are to teach others these abstract principles. As James Gee explains in the film, people don’t learn from abstract explanations of what really exists, rather they learn from hands on experience. However, there are concepts integral to the grade school learning curriculum such as literary technique and analysis, conceptual mathematics, and artistic expression that are either not suited to the limitations of a game template or would actually lose creative value if approached through gaming. How is a child to express full artistic intent though the limitations of a computer system? Quest to Learn is not interdisciplinary in that it restricts application and expression to media technologies, which are ultimately a degree removed from the ingenuity of the human brain because they are constructed by a computing device. Perhaps with more technological advancement, this restriction will be eradicated, but for now, gaming technologies are still relatively infantile and can not reflect the full range of activities and aspects facilitated by a brain and a multifaceted non-digital world. System-based learning can go one of two ways. 1) It can propagate the user/creator to push media technologies to their limits by striving continually to marry systems and theory or 2) It can shape young brains to think systematically, training students to regard the world in parts and wholes that can be manipulated and evaluated like the parts of a game, leaving the individual to think more methodically and less conceptually which is perhaps inherently dangerous to a race of “dreaming” individuals. Do we want young brains to be shaped strictly along the lines of what is ultimately artistic engineering?
Furthermore, Quest School seems to encourage its students to view the world and share ideas through screens and lenses, which implements a methodology of simulation. Are Quest students indeed interacting more with their world, or are they removing themselves from it within the classroom? This brings up the question of “authentic” interaction within a simulated environment.
I’m not sure if the larger education system will indeed adopt the gaming pedagogy style of Learning because it encourages radical creation along with bottom-up teaching methods and collectivity in a nation/world based on individualization. This view is purely political, though. The truth is, I don’t believe that the masses believe in play enough and are therefore skeptical of the incentives and effectiveness of gaming schools.
Having said all this, I would choose to send my child to this school and what’s more, I’d like to work at it. Despite my apparent level of skepticism in this blog, I believe in this method of education more than that which is the standard in America right now and it is an interesting experiment for this country’s future.